Could a Dad’s Army government do more for farmers?

As a big fan of 70’s sitcom Dad’s Army re-runs, I can’t help noticing there seem to be certain analogies between the TV programme and the current predicament of UK agriculture.

Like most farmers, I have to be an optimist and always expect the weather to be kind, yields to be good and prices to be high for my produce. In reality, it is usually a curate’s egg of a year with good bits and bad, but this year appears to be more like a verger’s egg. In other words, it has been a bumbling lick spittle mess of a year with everything conspiring against us. A bit like the way Mr Yeatman, in his eagerness to please the vicar, always says and does the wrong thing.

My oilseed rape has been a disaster yield wise, with a measly 0.62 tonne per hectare, despite the fact it all came through the winter looking small but well. The incessant wet followed by the scorching dry and relentless flea beetle attack has taken its toll. The wheat was slightly better with a yield on 7.9 tonne per hectare of a 25 per cent reduction on a good year. Spring barley is looking good so far with one field doing 10 tonne per hectare, but I am not convinced the others will do as well.

Getting back to Dad’s Army: we seem to be being led in Westminster by a Captain Mainwaring character who has little knowledge of what he is doing, reacts in a knee jerk way to situations, and thinks if he says a few enthusiastic platitudes everything will be fine. Take the Agriculture Bill which has now finished its passage through parliament. The golden opportunity to set our leading standards of welfare and the environment in statute so that they would not be undermined in any trade deal with the US, or other country, has been squandered due to his desperation for a deal with anyone at any cost.


More from East Midlands Bylines:


The UK holds very few cards and I can imagine the US being like Private Walker rubbing his hands with glee as he spots a desperate punter to take advantage of. We are constantly told that nothing will be allowed in that is below our high standards. If this is true then why are thousands of tonnes of oilseed rape being allowed in that have been grown using neonicotinoids? Will this stop at the end of the transition period? I doubt it. How can we trust the Government without it being protected by law? They promised oven ready deals with the European Union (EU), and told us it would be the easiest thing in the world to make an agreement, and farmers would get more support payments.

These are just some of the lies we were told, and many people believed them. I think that if Private Jones were to be given charge of organising things in the event of no deal, he could have done a better job. Look at Chris (failing) Grayling and his supposed ferry company that had no ferries. Are we heading towards an agriculture policy similarly devoid of any agriculture? All the talk of public money for public goods is a meaningless sound bite.

Some of us are involved with the Save British Farming campaign. The Daily Mail has even mounted a campaign to ‘Save our family farms,’ as those farms seem to be the most vulnerable going forward. I’m not going to use Private Fraser’s favourite line of “we’re doomed”, because the world will keep turning and the land will be farmed, albeit by many fewer farmers. Remember the miners, the car workers, the ship builders and how they were treated during the 70s and 80s? Now it is the turn of UK agriculture to get the same treatment, and most farmers seem to be adopting the Sergeant Wilson approach of raising an eyebrow, smiling wryly and carrying on as if nothing was happening. I for one am not going to take this lying down and will fight for what is right just like Private Sponge, who incidentally was also a farmer, and his platoon.

‘Who do you think you are kidding Mr Johnson…?’


Please donate, follow us or sign up for the newsletter